Monday, September 8, 2014

M: freshmen defiantly shouldn't read this book because of its inaccurate information
E: The author creates a lot of flawed stereotypes about girls and their social rank for instance,“She’s the Queen Bee, the epitome of ten perfection.Through a combination of charisma, force,money, looks, will, and social intelligence, this girl reigns supreme over the other girls and weakens their friendships with others thereby strengthening  her own power and influence”(87).
A: considering this example you can see that this assumption is completely incorrect. Most schools have groups of people with similar interests however, they are not even close to the extreme scenarios the author described. the only logical conclusion that can be drawn from this evidence is that the book should not be read by freshman because of the false information
E: in addition the author also included a map on page 102 AND 103 that demonstrate where different groups “hang out”. for example the cheerleader and jocks only hang out in the senior hall next to the popular girls and guys. The asians hang out in front of the smelly gym with the choir girls.
A: this evidence suggests that this “map” is completely inaccurate because It is very uncommon to see a group of people that have a designated area in which they frequently hangout. the evidence revealed  proves that the information in the story in imprecise and unreliable which demonstrates why students shouldn't read this book
T: The content provided in this book is extremely inaccurate their for freshmen should not read this book



M: the unrelatable content topic is another one of the reasons that freshmen should not read this parent guide
E: for example, the author says that if you find out your daughter is having a party the appropriate thing to do is..“around 8:00PM turn off all the lights and have an adult sit on the front steps and tell people the party is off. then ground her and cut off her lines of communication for at least two weeks”(378).
A: based on the evidence  it is clear that most students wont relate to this quote mainly because most teens would strongly disagree with this punishment. considering this one can conclude that the topic is disconnecting to teens and it would be challenging for freshmen to read
E: furthermore many headings read as “What should you say when you child tells you someone is being mean to them? (60) and whats you parenting style? (112)
A: this evidence is important because it clearly demonstrates that because this book is designed for parents and is hard for students to connect to. Its difficult for a reader to stay focused when the author isn't talking directly towards you.from this evidence it is clear that if students were to read this book it would be hard to keep them interested
T: No one wants to read a book they can't connect with because it is both hard to ear and its also boring which is exactly why freshman students shouldn't read this book.





M: because of its confusing format freshman should not read the book
E: through out the book in the middle of a paragraph the author will redirect the reader to a different chapter an example of this is on page 37 the author states, “…she has to apologize to that person in person (see p.227 for apologies)…”
A: through this evidence you can easily predict that the reader may be confused while reading the book, because it hard to stay focused when the author is haven you constantly jump from chapter to chapter. It would be extremely difficult for freshman to stay on track throughout the course of the book
E: another example would be during one of the chapters the author was telling a story and in-between  every paragraph  or two she would insert a group of quotes 366-368.
A: considering this example, its easy to understand that this may be frustrating to the reader because it docent allow the story to flow and their for it will be harder for the reader to understand.

T:  the confusing format is a valid reason why freshmen should not read the book 

No comments:

Post a Comment